Chicago then and now

Wrigley Field, c. 1969

Wrigley Field, August 29, 2012

It's nice to see that some things never change.

The obvious differences in the two photos taken by the same photographer, yours truly, 43 years apart, are the high rise apartment building beyond the scoreboard, and the bleacher seats on the roof of the building just past the outfield wall on Waveland Avenue. Back in 1969 there was no advertising in the park; today it's slowly creeping in, very judiciously. One less obvious but enormous difference: if you check the time on the clock in the later photo, you'll realize this was taken before the start of a night game and as everyone knows, back in 1969 there were no lights in the ballpark, hence no night games.

You might notice the flags flying above the scoreboard, one for every team in the National League, one standard for each division. Today there are three divisions and standards as opposed to two, accounting for the expansion that has happened since 1969. The flags were and are still arranged by each team's standing in their respective division. I'm guessing the picture at the top was made in July or August of '69 meaning the Cubs flag would have been flying at the very top. Yesterday it was flying much closer to the bottom.

One poignant comparison: look at the guy at the right edge of the lower photograph wearing the number 10 Ron Santo jersey. In the photo at the top is the real Ron Santo at third base. You can also see Ernie Banks at first base. I could name the rest of the Cubs position players on the field, but I won't bore you. It looks like they were playing the Cincinnati Reds. If that's true, there would have been at least eight hall of famers (four for the Cubs, at least that many for the Reds), either on the field or on the bench that day, and one more who should be there in my humble opinion, Pete Rose.

I can't say for sure but I seriously doubt that my son and I saw eight future hall of famers last night. But the old ballpark is still there as you can see, pretty much as it looked, if not felt, when I was his age.

How much longer that will be is anyone's guess as there is still heated conversation about what to do with Wrigley Field. More than likely the 98 year old ballpark was not intended to last this long and clearly work needs to be done to keep it standing. My preference would be to bring it up to code but keep it essentially as it is. All the inconveniences, drunken frat boys and their girlfriends notwithstanding, it's still the best damn place on earth to see a baseball game.

Chicago, then and now...

The photograph on the left by Jack Delano was made in May of 1943, looking north toward the Illinois Central Freight Yards and the North Michigan Avenue Skyline. Surprisingly much of what is shown in the picture still exists, although virtually none of it is visible today from Delano's vantage on the Monroe Street Bridge. The Pabst Blue Ribbon sign of course is long gone as are the box cars. But the tracks still serve the Metra and South Shore commuter rail lines as they terminate just to the north at the Randolph Street Terminal underneath what is now Millennium Park. Also visible in the photograph from left to right are the Carbide & Carbon Building, (today the Hard Rock Hotel), the London Guarantee Building, the New Republic Building, the Wrigley Building, Tribune Tower and way off in the distance, the Palmolive Building, all still prominent, albeit diminished features of the north Loop skyline.

Here is the same view today taken from roughly the same vantage point, (with a much wider lens). Only the Carbide & Carbon Building is still visible although you have to look hard to find it.

It is stunning to see that in the 67 years since Delano's photograph, an entirely new city was built over the railroad tracks. I can recall a time, before the Monroe parking lot was covered over, and long before Millennium Park was conceived, when the area bounded by a little strip of park just east of Michigan Avenue, Monroe Street, Lake Shore Drive, and the River, was a foreboding, wind swept, semi-industrial landscape, that was accessible only by serious urban hikers and spelunkers, or by automobile.

Here is another of Delano's photographs of the same subject, taken at track level at night.

How times have changed. Today this piece of real estate just north of Grant Park is arguably the focal point of the city.

The Delano photograph comes from a series of color photographs recently published on-line by the Denver Post, (thank you Francis), which was made for the Farm Securities Administration between 1939 and 1943. The FSA was perhaps most famous for producing under the direction of Roy Stryker, a sweeping documentary project of rural poverty during the Depression. The project featured the work of Delano, and Russell Lee as well as the more familiar names of Dorothea Lange, Walker Evans, and Gordon Parks. Click here to see much more. Lange's iconic photograph of a migrant mother with her children was made for the project as well as many of the photographs that comprised Evans' seminal work, a book entitled simply, American Photographs.

Kodachrome, the late, great color slide film was introduced in 1935, but practical means to re-produce color prints in books and magazines, (the primary outlet for documentary photography) did not come around until much later. Consequently color photographs from this era did not get much attention until recently.

My wife once told me that as a child she believed that the world before 1960 was in black and white. While that thought never actually occurred to me, I must say it is quite stunning to see the world of the thirties and early forties in color, we simply think of that time in terms of black and white. The incredible saturation of Kodachrome, especially in the reds and yellows, was unmatched by any other medium to this day. And the film is without a doubt the most stable of all color photographic processes. Were it not for the fashion and automobiles styles of that bygone era, much of this work seems as fresh and vibrant as if it had been made yesterday.